stj.fyi home
Search

Search stj.fyi

    All results and filters

    Car rentals

    Compare St. John car rental agencies by location and vehicle type. Book early in high season: the island’s fleet is small.

    Filters (1)

    5 of 23 rental agenciesClear filters

    Open agencies first, then A–Z.

    Results

    • C & C Car Rental

      Car rentalCruz Bay

      Budget rates from $80 a day for Wranglers and small SUVs, free pickup anywhere on St. John; renters 25+.

    • Paul's Car & Jeep Rental

      Car rentalCruz Bay

      Wrangler Willys and small SUVs from $115 a day with free pickup; renters 26+ with US insurance, cars stay on St. John.

    • Sunshine's Jeep Rental

      Car rentalCruz Bay

      2026–27 rates from $105 a day, free pickup at both Cruz Bay ferry docks and the Westin; renters 25+.

    • Discount Car Rental (St. Thomas)

      Car rentalSt. Thomas

      St. Thomas airport-area agency that lets its 4WD and AWD vehicles go to St. John on the car barge at no extra fee.

      11 mi from Cruz Bay (straight line)
    • Lionel Jeep Rental

      Car rentalCruz Bay

      Wranglers, Broncos and SUVs with a free shuttle to the ferry dock; renters 25+, no Lameshur, no St. Thomas.